Reviewed by Arthur Geller, Auto Lease Concierge · Updated · How our numbers work
Yes, you can negotiate a car lease, and you should. I spent more than 10 years in dealership sales, finance and management, including the finance office where the lease paperwork gets signed. The short version: negotiate the price of the car, not the payment, and compare every quote on the total it costs you over the lease.
What can you actually negotiate on a lease?
| Open to negotiation | Set by someone else |
|---|---|
| The price of the car | The bank's lease program for that month |
| Your trade-in value, including a car still on a lease | Sales tax (about 9% on each payment in most of PA, about 11% in Philadelphia) |
| Add-ons in the finance office | State title and registration fees |
| How much you pay at signing | Which incentives you qualify for (loyalty, conquest, military, recent grad) |
| Term and miles a year (they change the payment) | Your credit tier |
The right-hand column is where people waste their energy. A salesperson can't change the bank's program or the state's fees. What they can change is the price of the car, and that's where most of the difference between two quotes comes from.
Why you negotiate the price, not the payment
Any payment can be made to look lower. Add six months to the term, drop from 10,000 to 7,500 miles a year, or put another $2,000 down, and the payment falls without the deal getting any better. That's the oldest move in the four-square, and I explain it in how the dealer four-square works.
So agree on the price first. Then look at the payment, the term, the miles and the total due at signing together, all four, in writing. To see exactly how a lower price flows into the payment, read how a car lease payment is calculated.
How to tell if a quote is a good one
Add it up. Total lease cost = due at signing + the monthly payment × the payments left after signing (the first payment is usually part of what's due at signing, so count it once).
| Example | Quote A | Quote B |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment | $399 | $369 |
| Term | 36 months | 36 months |
| Due at signing | $2,000 | $3,500 |
| Miles a year | 10,000 | 10,000 |
| Total cost | $15,965 | $16,415 |
Example only, not a current offer. Same term, miles and credit tier on both sides.
Quote B has the lower payment and costs $450 more. If the two quotes have different terms, divide each total by its number of months and compare that. To see what leases are going for around Philadelphia right now, check my monthly lease price report.
Five moves that work
- Get the same car quoted the same way. Same trim, term, miles and due at signing from every store, or the comparison means nothing.
- Ask for the total due at signing, in writing. One all-in number. If the store won't put it in writing, the payment isn't real yet.
- Ask which incentives are in the number. Loyalty and conquest offers can make a real difference, but only if you qualify and only if they're actually applied. Ask for them by name.
- Keep the trade-in separate. Get the car's price first, then the trade-in value. If your current car is leased, ask what your payoff is versus what it's worth; there may be money in it. See trading in a leased car.
- Be ready to walk. Lease programs run all month. Another store, or the same store next week, can write the same car.
What to watch for in the finance office
I sat in that chair, so here's the honest version: the finance office is where add-ons show up. Paint and fabric protection, tire and wheel coverage, theft etching and service plans can be worth it for some people, but every one of them is optional and every one raises your payment. Ask for the payment without them, and only add the ones you actually want. The FTC's guidance on dealer add-ons says the same: you don't have to buy them to get the car.
Before you sign, check that the contract matches what you agreed to: the price, term, miles, payment and due at signing. The FTC's guide to financing or leasing a car walks through the lease disclosures you should get.
Don't hand over your credit details first
You don't need to run your credit to get a real number on a specific car. Agree on the numbers first, then fill out a secure Credit Application. Never send your Social Security number, date of birth or income by text or email, to me or to anyone else.
Got a quote from a dealer?
Send me the quote you got and I’ll tell you if it’s fair, and if I can beat it.